You are currently viewing “Caroline” reviewed

“Caroline” reviewed

Suspense hangs over Caroline, Preston Max Allen’s new play enjoying a world premiere at MCC Theater, from the moment we first see Maddie (Chloe Grace Moretz) ordering mac and cheese and a brownie in a diner with her nine-year-old daughter, the show’s titular character (River Lipe-Smith). They’re driving from their home in West Virginia to meet Maddie’s estranged mother in the tony Chicago suburb of Evanston. But why is there such urgency? What caused Caroline to have a broken arm? And what waits behind the door when Maddie reunites with her mother?

Allen provides answers to all of these questions – and offers even more explanations over the course of this intimate three-hander as it addresses, under the sensitive direction of David Cromer, its heavy themes with a velvet glove. Beyond plot, beyond issues, Caroline is a play about characters, about how people choose to relate to each other in a world where wounds never cease to persist – and are sometimes self-inflicted.

The play’s first few scenes are a seduction, in a sense. Yes, watching the honest interplay between mother and daughter clues us into the reasons for their sudden sojourn. Maddie has a history of substance abuse as a teenager, causing great damage and stealing large amounts of money from her family before running away and cutting off all contact. Her parents don’t even know that their Caroline exists.

And in a sense, Caroline doesn’t exist until we meet her. She is trans, and while Maddie unequivocally supports her, her boyfriend (not Caroline’s father; we later learn he died while she was a baby) does not – a violent outburst led to her daughter’s injury and left them little choice but to flee their home in search of domestic and financial support. But in a sense, this trip is what sets her free. It’s only at the diner where Caroline chooses her name. “Can you not tell them I’m trans?” Allen’s title character asks her mother in the play’s second scene. “Can’t I just be a girl?”

It’s in watching this duo’s natural rapport that Allen wins us over, completely and early on. Caroline may be a magical child – a playwright’s overly eager construct, easily able to articulate all her thoughts, fears, and needs – but Lipe-Smith is a marvel, playing her with a preternatural sense of observation and skill. Caroline questions Maddie with the curiosity her age would dictate, but also knows how to navigate her mother’s confession with sensitivity, and Lipe-Smith’s intonations – her hesitations, her cadences, her occasional up-speak – prove her to be an innately intuitive performer. She’s also a natural with comic timing. “You should get me a Switch,” Caroline says. “It’s a lot cheaper than surgery and it’ll distract me for years and years.”

And Moretz, returning to the New York stage after her debut in the harrowing The Library, is viscerally affecting as mama tiger Maddie. This is perhaps especially affecting once Maddie awkwardly reunites with her estranger mother, Rhea (Amy Landecker), and Moretz shows how she emotionally returns to the young woman who once lived in that home (Laura Jellinek designed the set, mostly composed of transient spaces like the diner booth and a motel room, and then several liminal spaces to suggest Rhea’s sterile-feeling home). She very much can go home again, but should she? The ensuing exchanges, a series of scenes in which two of the show’s three characters alternate onstage together, comprise a dance of reacquaintance. After her past misdeeds, Maddie may get what she needs for Caroline – but at a price.

It’s tricky to talk about Caroline for a few reasons. First of all, because it’s to be applauded for telling a very contemporary story through a well-intentioned lens, and because its heart is so firmly in the right place that even minor criticism feels like sacrilege.

But throw tiny stones I must. Caroline, refreshingly, is not a political play, but the play shifts course in a manner that is not a surprise but comes so late it will not get spoiled here. As it teeters on the verge of domestic drama, one wishes that Allen didn’t make the play so one-sided. A very good Landecker is hamstrung by a play that never wants the audience to root for her, despite very justified reasons: Rhea and her husband will always be haunted by the same behavior Maddie wishes she could forget – but Maddie’s accountability and contrition automatically win over our sympathies. (It’s a missed opportunity that the character’s actions never once contradict or call into question anything that she ever does). It is also a cheat for the major late-play hurdle to be thrown by an unseen character, and that much of the drama derives only from past deeds which are discussed but never shown.

But again, those quibbles are outweighed but the good. Humane and hopeful, Caroline is without a doubt a play to root for.

Caroline
MCC Theater Space
www.mcctheater.org