You are currently viewing The Dating Shame: “Strategic Love Play” reviewed

The Dating Shame: “Strategic Love Play” reviewed

Dating is never easy, an evergreen truth that has provided fodder for many a play. Miriam Battye’s Strategic Love Play, now playing at the Minetta Lane Theatre in an Audible Theater production after a successful bow at the Edinburgh Fringe Festival, takes a barbed view of the current hookup scene – but her take is so askance I fear it almost entirely misses its intended target.

In this case, girl arranges to meet boy at a bar after meeting on a dating app: For not fully-explained reasons, Jenny (Heléne Yorke) seems ready to self-sabotage her date with Adam (Michael Zegen), a nice guy – who evinces what we have come to call of late “mediocre” – who goes on and on about a crush he harbors for another woman. Almost immediately, Jenny decides that Adam isn’t Mr. Right. He probably isn’t even Mr. Tonight. But she does want to taunt him – telling him that dating at their age isn’t about love but about strategy. Suddenly their date turns into a plan for a potential future the two might have together – a partnership without love, but maybe with benefits.

“I’m not what you want,” she tells Adam. “You’re not what I want. Stay with me.”

And so their date turns into a series of hypotheticals, a ploy on Battye’s part to get the characters to open reveal who they are to the audience. But it feels very forced, given that throughout the show, Adam feels a hostage victim responding to Jenny’s changing whims under duress. Throughout the show’s 70-minute running time, one can’t help but wonder why he doesn’t leave. Who would want to stay?

Some things may be lost in colloquial translation with Strategic Love Play. Battye hasn’t tweaked her dialogue at all for either New York characters or a New York audience, and the phrases fall like lead balloons. When Adam mentions bodies “bopping about” during sex or having a mouth that feels like “a dry little bean pot, it feels glaringly foreign to him for him.

Additionally, Yorke and Zegen are solid actors – and their work on the TV shows The Other Two and The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel show their respective facility for slinging a wicked barb and navigating nimble comic timing – but they are probably a little too old to play these roles. Hovering around 40, their characters feel, well, too old for this. Director Katie Posner struggles to give us a reason to root for them. She has essentially directed them as though they were in two different shows. Not only are their characters disparate – their acting styles clash: Yorke’s is broad and brusque, while Zegen’s are small.

Similarly, Jen Schriever’s lighting doesn’t do enough to telegraph the passage of time. (Whether the action takes place in the continuous moment, or over a series of encounters, remains unclear.) Background noise in Tei Blow’s sound design appears to come and go at will—there is never a sense that Jenny and Adam are really in a crowded, busy bar. Strategic Love Play will be recorded and released by Audible sometime in the future, and that feels like a smart, strategic choice.

Ultimately, though, Strategic Love Play can’t get past its Jenny, a creation so vulgar, so impossible to root for, so singlehandedly willing to drive the show’s encounter straight into the ground that there’s not only never any doubt as to whether there will be a love match afoot but there’s also no fun in watching this swan dive. It’s hard to invest too much in a show that, like it heroine, sets itself up for failure from the outset. But what’s lacking throughout the play’s often-repetitive 70-minute running time is strategy.

Strategic Love Play
Minette Lane Theatre
www.strategicloveplay.com