We first find Josh (Noah Galvin), the narrator and protagonist of Jake Brasch’s off-Broadway debut play The Reservoir, awaking on the banks of the Cherry Creek Reservoir in suburban Denver after a major, days-long bender. Unsure of how he got there, or where he received the giant gash on his arm, he is at least secure in the knowledge that much of his family lives nearby and will be there to pick his drunk ass off the floor. But don’t be fooled by this rough landing; The Reservoir is a show that otherwise always gives its flawed protagonist a soft place to fall.
On medical leave from NYU drama school (he explained on a form that he was “2 drunk 4 this”), he is supposed to be in rehab. He cannot remember the details of how he left, but ventures a guess: “They caught me fermenting grapefruit juice in the boiler room.” While he dries out, his exasperated mother (a wounded and wary Heidi Armbruster) gets him a part-time job shelving at the independent bookstore where she works as a buyer. But his brain fog is so severe that he struggles to remember the alphabet. Inconsistent with that fact, he also spends a lot of his on-the-clock time browsing books on cognitive science. All of this is extremely irritating to his middle-aged manager Hugo (Matthew Saldívar), who resents the nepo baby who gets paid for the extra work he’s doing.
“I’m sorry I care more about my family than alphabetizing and dusting,” Josh brattily retorts. While he is distressed about the state of his own brain, he was incensed to learn that his Nana Irene (Mary Beth Peil) has slipped fully into senility without anyone telling him. Surely science has an answer to their mutual problem, some super-food or exercise that will strengthen their cognitive reserves so Josh can spend more quality time with his four living grandparents, whom he had hitherto been neglecting in favor of Smirnoff Ice benders.
It’s easy to imagine the meeting at Atlantic Theater Company (which is co-producing this off-Broadway debut with Ensemble Studio Theatre) where The Reservoir was programmed into the season. “We need a play that will appeal to young people,” I hear artistic director Neil Pepe telling a small conference room of nervous not-for-profit administrators, “but one that also connects with our members who are … not as young.”
It’s a nice idea, but in practice The Reservoir repels more than it attracts. Part of this is Brasch’s writing, which isn’t as funny as it wants to be. The other part is Galvin, who despite considerable effort cannot fully sell this material or get us to truly invest in Josh’s sobriety journey. To really get milage out of a deeply flawed character who uses humor as a defense mechanism, one must actually disarm the audience with humor. ButBrasch thinks that dementia can mirror addiction – the lack of ballast, the quiet stigma, perhaps – but he ultimately uses the grandparents as a kind of community service to provide redemption for Josh. “See? He loves these people, he’s fine.” Also, he has no friends or high school acquaintances in his orbit?
At least The Reservoir offers a platform for excellent performances from some of New York’s very best veteran actors. Chip Zien is effortlessly hilarious as Shrimpy, Josh’s foul-mouthed Jewish grandfather who is studying for his second bar mitzvah (remembering the Hebrew becomes one of Josh’s cognitive exercises for Gramps). Peter Maloney heartbreakingly conveys the loneliness of a man whose life partner is suffering from severe dementia, an emotion mostly deflected through forced conversation about sports. But Peil lets us know that there is still something of the old Irene in there when she stands up at the nursing home cafeteria and sings a showstopping rendition of “O Come All Ye Faithful.”
Caroline Aaron gives the standout performance as Grandma Beverly. Long divorced from Shrimpy, she has her own history with alcoholism, which she reveals to Josh after he relapses on vanilla extract. “If she can ask for help, if she can forgive herself, if she can go to meetings with her two toddlers in between shifts,” she speaks of herself in the ’60s, “you can surely muster the strength given your subsidized suburban lifestyle to extract your head full of shitty thoughts right out of your ass.” Aaron is the embodiment of tough love, a dab of grandmotherly spit on Josh’s soiled collar.
But part of growing up is realizing that one’s personal struggles ultimately aren’t that interesting to most people—not even the family members who previously seemed to have unlimited time to listen. Brasch constantly gives his alter ego an out. Josh is always validated by someone else. The play distracts from the hard work required to fight addiction by supplying multiple grandparents with dementia; pain supplants misbehavior. The Reservoir also makes the character of the mother far from focal, turning the most burdened character into a footnote. Armbruster shouldn’t also play other roles, but Saldivar proves to be the show’s MVP. Galvin carries the show with aplomb.
I hope that The Reservoir fills its audiences with hope and insight, especially those struggling with addiction. But I found my patience drying up by the end.
